Home / Gym Challenge / Misty's Poliwag [1st Edition] #89
Misty's Poliwag [1st Edition] #89 Pokémon Card from Pokemon Gym Challenge Set

Misty's Poliwag [1st Edition] #89

Misty's Poliwag [1st Edition] #89 (Gym Challenge) sells for about $3.99 ungraded and $260 in PSA 10 (3 sales, latest Oct 3). PSA has graded 523 copies, 191 of them 10s. Prices are medians of completed sales, updated November 11, 2026.

Ungraded
$3.99
39 sales
Sales we held out are listed below, not counted here.
39 sold in 76 days · latest 3 days ago
$0.99 $12.08
$2.57 3 days ago Misty's Poliwag · Lightly Played · 1st Edition · English $2.53 5 days ago Misty's Poliwag · Lightly Played · 1st Edition · English $2.00 last week Misty's Poliwag · Lightly Played · 1st Edition · English $1.40 2 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag · Near Mint · 1st Edition · English $4.00 2 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag · Near Mint · 1st Edition · English $4.49 2 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag 089/132 1st Edition Common Gym Challenge NM Pokemon 089/132 $3.25 3 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Common Gym Challenge Pokemon 1st Edition MP 89/132 $11.92 4 weeks ago Pokemon Cards: Gym Challenge 1st Edition Common: Misty's Poliwag 89/132 #89 $1.50 4 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag · Lightly Played · 1st Edition · English $3.99 4 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Common Gym Challenge Pokemon 1st Edition NM 89/132 $3.14 4 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag 089/132 1st Edition Common Gym Challenge LP Pokemon 089/132 $5.09 4 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag 89/132 1st Edition Common Gym Challenge Pokemon Cards 89/132 $3.99 4 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Common Gym Challenge Pokemon 1st Edition Near Mint 89/132 $3.25 5 weeks ago Pokemon Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Gym Challenge Common 2000 Eng 50 HP 1st edition 89/132 $3.62 5 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag - 1st Edition - 89/132 Gym Challenge - Pokémon TCG - 2000 89/132 $6.99 5 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag - 1st Edition - 89/132 Gym Challenge - Pokémon TCG - 2000 89/132 $6.99 6 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag - 1st Edition - 89/132 Gym Challenge - Pokémon TCG - 2000 89/132 $2.57 6 weeks ago 1st edition Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Gym Challenge 2000 WoTC Pokemon TCG 89/132 $4.49 7 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Common Gym Challenge Pokemon 1st Edition Lightly Played 89/132 $6.99 7 weeks ago LP+ 1st Edition Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Gym Challenge Pokemon 2000 Ken Sugimori 89/132 $3.29 7 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag Gym Challenge 89/132 Common 1st Edition Pokemon TCG NM/LP 89/132 $6.36 7 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Common Gym Challenge Pokemon 1st Edition Near Mint 89/132 $12.08 7 weeks ago Pokemon TCG Cards 1st Edition Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Gym Challenge NM $3.99 8 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Common Gym Challenge Pokemon 1st Edition NM 89/132 $4.99 8 weeks ago Misty's Poliwag 89/132 1st Edition Common Gym Challenge Pokemon MP 89/132 $3.99 2 months ago Pokémon TCG: Misty's Poliwag 1ST EDITION Gym Challenge 89/132 Regular LP 89/132 $3.99 2 months ago [LP+/NM] 2000 Pokemon Gym Challenge Misty's Poliwag 1st Edition #89/132 Common 89/132 $3.99 2 months ago Misty's Poliwag 89/132 1st Edition Common Gym Challenge Pokemon Lightly Played 89/132 $6.95 2 months ago MISTY’S POLIWAG - 1st Edition Gym Challenge - 89/132 - Common - Pokemon - NM $4.29 2 months ago Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Gym Challenge 1st Edition Pokemon MP 89/132 $4.74 2 months ago Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Common Gym Challenge Pokemon 1st Edition Near Mint 89/132 $7.00 2 months ago Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Gym Challenge Pokemon 1st Edition Ken Sugimori 89/132 $5.00 2 months ago Pokémon TCG Pokémon TCG Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Gym Challenge 1st Edition LP $5.95 2 months ago 1st Edition Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Gym Challenge - Common Pokemon Card - NM/Mint $6.99 2 months ago Misty's Poliwag - 1st Edition - 89/132 Gym Challenge - Pokémon TCG - 2000 89/132 $0.99 2 months ago Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Gym Challenge First Edition Pokemon 1st 89/132 $3.25 2 months ago Misty's Poliwag 1st Edition Pokemon TCG Gym Challenge 89/132 NM/LP 089/132 $3.25 2 months ago 2000 Pokemon Gym Challenge 1st Edition #89/132 Misty's Poliwag 89/132 $6.01 2 months ago Pokemon TCG Vintage 1st Edition Misty's Poliwag 89/132 Gym Challenge 89/132

2 sales well outside the rest ($11.92, $12.08). A median is barely moved by them, which is why it is the number shown.

Also held for this card: 3 PSA 10, 5 PSA 9. Priced separately, never mixed into this median.

Every sale is a completed listing. Click any line to open it.

Price by grade
4 from real sales · 2 est
Grade PSA CGC BGS TAG SGC
10 Pristine
—
Buy ›
—
—
—
10 Buy › Buy ›
$333.00
est
—
$154.00
est
9.5
—
Buy ›
—
—
—
9 Buy › Buy ›
—
Buy ›
—
8.5
—
Buy ›
—
—
—
8 Buy › Buy ›
—
—
—
7.5
—
Buy ›
—
—
—
7 Buy ›
—
—
—
—
6 Buy ›
—
—
—
—
5 Buy ›
—
—
—
—

Medians of completed sales — click one to see them. Arrows compare the last 90 days with the period before. last sold means one or two sales, so we show the most recent one rather than a median. est is an estimate we have not confirmed. pop is how many exist at that grade. How we price

Grade it? 37% of 523 PSA-graded copies came back a 10. Raw $3.99 → PSA 10 $260.00. Expected value after PSA's fee ($60): +$51.40 per copy.
We grade it for you, $27 a card → Mail it to us. CGC Authorized Dealer: we check it, submit it and ship the slab back insured. No account, no forms.
Sales volume: Top 20% of cards
Get an email when the price moves
One email when it hits your price, with the cheapest copy on eBay. No account needed.
$
Buy on DoubleHolo
Price History
Raw PSA 10
Graded by
PSA
523
graded
36.5%
191 in PSA 10
CGC
321
graded
27.4%
88 at 10 or better
How CGC grades work
CGC grades above 9: Pristine sits above Gem Mint, Perfect above that.
Pristine 10 11 Gem Mint 10 77 9.5 10 9 109

These are two different pools of submissions, so this compares what each grader did, not what either would do with the same card.

Population Distribution

PSA 10 191
PSA 9 240
PSA 8 55
PSA 7 20
PSA 6 9
PSA 5 5
PSA 4 1
PSA 3 1
PSA 2 0
PSA 1 0

Need these prices and population counts in a spreadsheet or app? PokeInvest Data API

Affiliate disclosure: as an eBay Partner Network affiliate, PokeInvest earns from qualifying purchases made through eBay links on this page. The Double Holo button is a paid sponsorship.

eBay Listings BETA

Loading eBay listings...