Home / Fossil / Gengar [1st Edition] #5
Gengar [1st Edition] #5 Pokémon Card from Pokemon Fossil Set

Gengar [1st Edition] #5

Pokemon Fossil
Ungraded
$347.50
88 sales
Sales we held out are listed below, not counted here.
88 sold in 59 days · latest last week
$50.00 $2,382
$500.00 last week Gengar 5/62 Fossil 1st Edition Holo Rare 80 HP English 1999 Pokémon TCG $600.92 last week Gengar - 5/62 - Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Holo Rare Card WOTC LP $600.92 last week Gengar - 5/62 - Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Holo Rare Card WOTC LP $458.16 2 weeks ago Gengar (5) · Near Mint · 1st Edition Holofoil · English $400.00 2 weeks ago Gengar 1st Ed. Holo #5/62 LP- Fossil Pokemon Card 5/62 $305.00 2 weeks ago 1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Gengar #5/62 $219.99 2 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo Rare 1st Edition 1999 English Pokemon TCG HP 5/62 $365.00 2 weeks ago WOTC Pokémon TCG Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo Rare 1st Ed Eng 1999 80HP 5/62 $200.00 2 weeks ago Gengar [1st Edition] #5 Pokemon Fossil $74.99 2 weeks ago Fossil Gengar 5/62 1st Edition Holo Rare English Pokemon Card TCG 80 HP $455.00 2 weeks ago Wizards of the Coast Pokemon TCG Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo Rare 1st Ed 1999 $275.00 2 weeks ago 1st Edition Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo $250.00 2 weeks ago 1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition #5 Gengar Holo MP- 5/62 $150.00 2 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo Rare 1999 English 80 HP 1st Ed $420.75 2 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 Pokemon TCG 1st Edition Fossil Set 1999 Original Vintage WOTC LP 5/62 $577.00 2 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 Fossil 1st Edition Holo Rare Holo POKEMON LP 5/62 $436.62 3 weeks ago Gengar (5) 1st Edition Holo Rare Fossil 05/62 MP $279.99 3 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo 1st Edition $375.00 3 weeks ago 1st Edition Gengar Holo Rare 5/62 - Fossil Pokémon Card 1999 WOTC $440.00 3 weeks ago 1st Edition Gengar Holo Fossil 5/62 (1999) LP- PERFECT HOLO $373.66 3 weeks ago Gengar Holo 1st Edition 5/62 Pokémon 1999 Fossil WOTC Vintage Card $350.00 3 weeks ago 1st Edition Gengar Holo - Fossil 5/62 (1999 WOTC) - LP- HOLO $288.00 3 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 Fossil 1st Edition Holo Rare Pokemon 1999 MP 5/62 $2,382 3 weeks ago 1999 POKEMON FOSSIL GENGAR - HOLO 1ST EDITION #5 MINT 9 $416.25 3 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 Fossil 1st Edition Holo Rare English 80 HP Pokemon TCG Card $147.00 3 weeks ago Pokemon TCG Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo Rare English 1999 1st Edition $575.55 3 weeks ago 1999 Pokemon Gengar-Holo Fossil 1st Edition 5/62 NM $50.00 4 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo, Zapdos 1st Edition, Haunter 4/62 Holo $529.18 4 weeks ago Pokemon TCG Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo Rare English 1999 1st edition $639.85 4 weeks ago Pokémon TCG Gengar 1st Edition Holo Card Fossil 5/62 - ACE $421.00 4 weeks ago 1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition #5 Gengar Holo $1,058 4 weeks ago 1999 POKEMON FOSSIL GENGAR - HOLO 1ST EDITION #5 MINT 9 $425.00 4 weeks ago 1st Edition Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo $2,000 4 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo 1st edition $450.00 4 weeks ago WOTC Pokemon TCG First Edition Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo Rare Unlimited 1999 Qty 1 5/62 $229.80 4 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo Rare 1st Edition 1999 English Pokemon TCG 80 HP $549.99 4 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo 1st Edition $300.00 4 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 1st Edition Fossil Holo 1999 Pokémon 5/62 $560.18 4 weeks ago 1999 POKEMON FOSSIL 1ST EDITION #5/62 GENGAR HOLO RARE $285.00 4 weeks ago GENGAR 1st Edition Fossil Holo #5/62 $539.99 4 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 Fossil 1st Edition Holo Rare Holo POKEMON LP $284.47 4 weeks ago Vintage Pokémon TCG Gengar Fossil Holo Rare 5/62 1st Edition $377.50 4 weeks ago Pokemon TCG Gengar 5/62 Fossil 1st Edition Holo Rare 1999 English $250.00 4 weeks ago 1st Edition Gengar 5/62 Fossil 1999 Holo Rare WOTC Pokémon Card $324.99 4 weeks ago Pokémon Gengar Fossil 5/62 1st Edition Holo 1999 WOTC TCG Card LP $240.50 4 weeks ago Wizards of the Coast Pokemon TCG Gengar 5/62 Fossil 1st Edition Holo Rare $1,058 4 weeks ago Pokémon TCG Gengar 1st Edition Holo Card Fossil 5/62 $214.99 4 weeks ago Pokémon Gengar Fossil 5/62 1st Edition Holo 1999 WOTC TCG Card HP $282.77 4 weeks ago Gengar Fossil 5/62 1st Edition Holo Rare 1999 80 HP English Keiji Kinebuchi $239.99 4 weeks ago GENGAR 5/62 1ST EDITION FOSSIL HOLO MP $664.99 4 weeks ago Gengar (5/62) [Fossil 1st Edition] $300.00 5 weeks ago WOTC Pokemon TCG Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo Rare 1st Edition English 80 HP $330.00 5 weeks ago Pokemon TCG Gengar 5/62 Fossil 1st Edition Holo Rare English 1999 80 HP 5/62 $425.00 5 weeks ago The Pokémon Company Gengar 5/62 Fossil 1st Edition Holo Holo Rare 80 HP English 5/62 $289.00 5 weeks ago Pokemon 1st Edition Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo MP 5/62 $580.00 5 weeks ago Pokemon TCG Fossil Gengar 5/62 1st Edition Holo Rare 1999 English 5/62 $330.00 5 weeks ago Pokemon TCG Gengar 5/62 Fossil 1st Edition Holo Rare English 1999 80 HP $417.00 5 weeks ago 1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition #5/62 Gengar Holo $403.55 5 weeks ago Pokemon TCG Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo Rare English 1999 1st edition $344.93 5 weeks ago Gengar 1st Edition Fossil 5/62 NM Pokemon $663.93 5 weeks ago Gengar Holo 1st Edition 5/62 Pokémon 1999 Fossil WOTC Vintage Card $138.93 5 weeks ago Wizards of the Coast Gengar 5/62 Fossil 1st Edition Non Holo Clean $421.00 5 weeks ago 1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition #5 Gengar Holo $132.00 5 weeks ago 1999 Pokemon Fossil 5 Gengar-Holo 1st Edition Rare 5/62 5/62 $331.00 6 weeks ago 1st Edition Gengar Holo Rare 5/62 - Fossil Pokémon Card 1999 WOTC 5/62 $330.78 6 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 1st Edition Holo Fossil Set Pokemon TCG $170.00 6 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo, Zapdos 1st Edition, Haunter 4/62 Holo $200.00 6 weeks ago Pokemon TCG Fossil Gengar 5/62 1st Edition Holo Rare 80 HP English 1999 $270.00 6 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo 1st Edition $220.00 6 weeks ago 1999 Pokemon Gengar-Holo Unlimited 5/62 NM WOTC RARE CARD 5/62 $210.00 6 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 1st Edition Fossil Holo Rare ENG 80 HP Keiji Kinebuchi $208.00 6 weeks ago 1999 Pokémon TCG Fossil 1st Edition Gengar Holo Rare Card 5/62 5/62 $315.00 6 weeks ago 1999 Pokémon TCG Fossil 1st Edition Gengar Holo Rare Card 5/62 $288.00 6 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo 1st Edition $200.00 7 weeks ago Gengar 5/62 Fossil 1st Edition Holo Rare English Stage 2 80HP Pokémon 5/62 $815.00 7 weeks ago Pokemon Gengar Holo Rare 1st Edition 5/62 Fossil 1999 1st Edition NM ✨✨ 5/62 $371.00 7 weeks ago Pokémon Gengar TCG 1st Edition Holo Fossil Card 5/62 5/62 $386.00 7 weeks ago 1999 Pokemon Fossil Gengar #5/62 Holo 1st Edition Rare Old School Wizards WOTC 5/62 $330.00 8 weeks ago 1999 Pokemon 1st Edition Rare Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo 5/62 $350.00 8 weeks ago Pokemon TCG Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo Rare Unlimited English Wizards 1999 5/62 $197.09 2 months ago Pokemon Card/Card - Gengar 5/62 - Fossil Holo Swirl 1st Edition - Very Good+ $533.05 2 months ago Gengar #5 1st Edition Fossil Holo Rare Pokemon 1999 LP 5/62 $700.00 2 months ago 1999 Pokémon TCG Fossil 1st Edition Gengar Holo Rare Card 5/62 5/62 $345.00 2 months ago 1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Gengar Holo 5/62 WOTC Vintage - LP 5/62 $426.90 2 months ago 1999 Pokémon Gengar 5/62 1st Edition Fossil Holo Rare WOTC English NM/LP 5/62 $250.00 2 months ago Pokemon TCG Gengar 5/62 Fossil Holo Rare 1st Ed Stage 2 80HP EN 1999 WOTC 5/62 $240.00 2 months ago Pokémon TCG Fossil Gengar Holo Rare First Edition 5/62 Holo HP 5/62 $1,700 2 months ago Gengar 5/62 Fossil 1st Edition Holo Rare English Pokémon TCG Card 5/62

6 sales well outside the rest ($2,382, $1,058, $2,000). A median is barely moved by them, which is why it is the number shown.

Also held for this card: 1 ACE 8, 1 BGS 4.5, 2 BGS 7.5, 6 BGS 8, 8 BGS 8.5, 3 BGS 9, 1 BGS 9.5, 9 CGC 10, 1 CGC 3.5, 1 CGC 7, 3 CGC 7.5, 1 CGC 8, 2 CGC 8.5, 9 CGC 9, 2 CGC 9.5, 3 PSA 1, 4 PSA 10, 1 PSA 1.5, 1 PSA 2, 2 PSA 3, 2 PSA 4, 12 PSA 5, 21 PSA 6, 34 PSA 7, 30 PSA 8, 1 PSA 8.5, 37 PSA 9, 2 TAG 6, 1 TAG 8. Priced separately, never mixed into this median.

Every sale is a completed listing. Click any line to open it.

Price by grade
19 from real sales
Grade PSA CGC BGS ACE TAG SGC
10 Pristine
—
—
—
—
—
10
—
—
—
—
9.5
—
—
—
9
—
—
—
8.5
—
—
—
8
—
7.5
—
—
—
—
7
—
—
—
—
6.5
—
—
—
—
—
6
—
—
—
—
5.5
—
—
—
—
—
5
—
—
—
—
—
4.5
—
—
—
—
4
—
—
—
—
—
3.5
—
—
—
—
—
3
—
—
—
—
2
—
—
—
—
—
1.5
—
—
—
—
—

Medians of completed sales — click one to see them. Arrows compare the last 90 days with the period before. last sold means one or two sales, so we show the most recent one rather than a median. est is an estimate we have not confirmed. pop is how many exist at that grade. How we price

Grade it? 2% of 7,962 PSA-graded copies came back a 10. Raw $345.00 → PSA 10 $49,000. Expected value after a $25 fee: +$3,359 per copy. Mostly from the 9, which sells for $2,664.
Run the full math →
Sales volume: Top 10% of cards
View eBay Listings Buy on TCGplayer Should I grade it?
Price History
Raw PSA 10
Graded by
PSA
7,962
graded
2.3%
183 in PSA 10
CGC
1,386
graded
11.3%
157 at 10 or better

CGC has given this card a ten 4.9× as often — 11.3% against 2.3%.

How CGC grades work
CGC grades above 9: Pristine sits above Gem Mint, Perfect above that.
Pristine 10 8 Gem Mint 10 149 9.5 49 9 342

These are two different pools of submissions, so this compares what each grader did, not what either would do with the same card.

Population Distribution

PSA 10 183
PSA 9 2000
PSA 8 2360
PSA 7 1376
PSA 6 929
PSA 5 586
PSA 4 235
PSA 3 92
PSA 2 39
PSA 1 66

Affiliate disclosure: as an eBay Partner Network affiliate, PokeInvest earns from qualifying purchases made through eBay links on this page.

eBay Listings BETA

Loading eBay listings...

View More on eBay

Similar Cards

Lapras [1999-2000] #25 from Pokemon Fossil set
Lapras [1999-2000] #25
Same Set
$362.51
Booster Pack from Pokemon Fossil set
Booster Pack
Same Set
$306.17
Dragonite [1st Edition] #4 from Pokemon Fossil set
Dragonite [1st Edition] #4
Same Set
$256.81
Lockdown Theme Deck from Pokemon Fossil set
Lockdown Theme Deck
Same Set
$221.85
Booster Pack [1st Edition] from Pokemon Fossil set
Booster Pack [1st Edition]
Same Set
$515.42
BodyGuard Theme Deck from Pokemon Fossil set
BodyGuard Theme Deck
Same Set
$155.00
More on this card: Compare graders PSA 10 price & pop Should you grade it? Every Gengar card Fossil PSA population