Home / Neo Genesis / Magby #23
Magby #23 Pokémon Card from Pokemon Neo Genesis Set

Magby #23

Magby #23 (Neo Genesis) sells for about $2.74 ungraded and $59 in PSA 10. PSA has graded 150 copies, 20 of them 10s. Prices are medians of completed sales, updated November 2, 2026.

Pokemon Neo Genesis
Ungraded
$2.74
62 sales
Sales we held out are listed below, not counted here.
62 sold in 52 days · latest 6 days ago
$0.83 $11.95
$1.36 6 days ago Magby · Moderately Played · Unlimited · English $1.39 last week Magby · Moderately Played · Unlimited · English $1.60 last week Magby · Lightly Played · Unlimited · English $1.84 last week Magby · Lightly Played · Unlimited · English $2.99 last week Magby · Lightly Played · Unlimited · English $2.08 2 weeks ago Magby · Lightly Played · Unlimited · English $1.70 2 weeks ago Magby · Lightly Played · Unlimited · English $1.92 2 weeks ago Magby · Lightly Played · Unlimited · English $1.90 2 weeks ago Magby · Moderately Played · Unlimited · English $6.99 2 weeks ago 2000 Pokemon Magby 23/111 Neo Genesis Non Holo Rare Unlimited WOTC Vintage 23/111 $1.12 2 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Neo Genesis English Pokemon Cards Excellent $2.48 3 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Rare Neo Genesis Pokemon Unlimited Moderately Played Ken Sugimori 23/111 $0.99 3 weeks ago Pokemon Magby Neo Genesis N1 23/111 Rare Fire Basic Baby Live Coal 23/111 $4.49 3 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Neo Genesis Pokemon Unlimited Ken Sugimori 23/111 $1.97 3 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Neo Genesis Rare Pokemon Card 23/111 $2.60 3 weeks ago 2001 Pokémon Neo Genesis Magby 23/111 Non-Holo Rare MT-NM 23/111 $3.30 3 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Rare Neo Genesis Pokemon Unlimited Near Mint 23/111 $1.13 3 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Neo Genesis English Pokemon Cards Excellent $3.75 3 weeks ago 2000 Pokemon 23/111 Magby (Neo Genesis) NM 23/111 $5.30 3 weeks ago Pokemon Cards Magby 23/111 Unlimited Neo Genesis Rare NM 23/111 $2.00 3 weeks ago MAGBY - Neo Genesis Set - 23/111 - Rare - Pokemon Card - Unlimited - NM 23/111 $2.25 3 weeks ago Pokemon Neo Genesis Magby 23/111 Unlimited Rare Mp 23/111 $9.29 3 weeks ago Pokemon Card Magby 23/111 Neo Genesis WOTC Vintage Rare LP 2000 23/111 $2.75 4 weeks ago 2000 Pokemon 23/111 Magby (Neo Genesis) LP 23/111 $1.75 4 weeks ago Magby Pokemon Neo Genesis 23/111 Unlimited Rare 23/111 $1.99 4 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Rare Neo Genesis Pokemon Unlimited Moderately Played 23/111 $5.99 4 weeks ago Magby - 23/111 Neo Genesis - Pokémon TCG - 2000 23/111 $4.91 4 weeks ago Magby - 23/111 - Pokemon Neo Genesis Unlimited Rare Card WOTC LP $5.49 4 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Rare Neo Genesis Pokemon Unlimited Lightly Played 23/111 $2.45 4 weeks ago Magby · Near Mint · Unlimited · English $6.63 4 weeks ago Magby 23/111 (Neo Genesis, Unlimited, Rare, LP) Pokemon TCG 23/111 $0.83 4 weeks ago Magby · Moderately Played · Unlimited · English $2.73 4 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Neo Genesis English Pokemon Cards Excellent $1.75 4 weeks ago Magby · Lightly Played · Unlimited · English $6.00 5 weeks ago Magby 23/111 (Neo Genesis, Unlimited, Rare, LP) Pokemon TCG 23/111 $4.44 5 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Rare Neo Genesis Pokemon Unlimited Near Mint 23/111 $2.85 5 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Neo Genesis English Pokemon Cards Excellent $2.19 5 weeks ago Magby 023/111 Unlimited Neo Genesis MP Pokémon TCG 023/111 $3.74 5 weeks ago Magby - 23/111 - Pokemon Neo Genesis Unlimited Rare Card WOTC - MP $6.95 6 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Neo Genesis Pokemon TCG Common/Uncommon Non Holo VG Condition 23/111 $1.99 6 weeks ago NEO GENESIS MAGBY 23/111 R POKEMON UNLIMITED MP 23/111 $5.18 6 weeks ago Magby - 23/111 - Pokemon Neo Genesis Unlimited Rare Card WOTC LP $9.95 6 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Neo Genesis - Rare Pokemon Card - NM/Mint $1.99 6 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Neo Genesis Regular Pokemon Card 1995-2000 23/111 $3.75 6 weeks ago 2000 Pokemon Neo Genesis Magby #23/111 $1.15 6 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Neo Genesis English Pokemon Cards Excellent $3.00 7 weeks ago Pokémon TCG Magby Neo Genesis Card 23/111 Regular Rare, Unlimited 23/111 $2.99 7 weeks ago Magby Unlimited Rare Pokémon Neo Genesis 023/111 NM 023/111 $1.69 7 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Rare Neo Genesis Pokemon Unlimited Near Mint 23/111 $2.99 7 weeks ago Pokemon Card Neo Genesis Magby 23/111 Unlimited Rare 23/111 $1.69 7 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Rare Neo Genesis Pokemon Unlimited Near Mint 23/111 $2.99 7 weeks ago Pokemon TCG Magby 023/111 Unlimited - Neo Genesis 023/111 $3.49 7 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Rare Neo Genesis Pokemon Unlimited Lightly Played 23/111 $3.99 7 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Unlimited Rare Neo Genesis Pokemon LP 23/111 $4.99 7 weeks ago Pokemon Card - Magby Neo Genesis 23/111 Rare Non Holo 23/111 $2.99 7 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Unlimited Rare Neo Genesis Pokemon Cards 23/111 $11.95 7 weeks ago MAGBY - Neo Genesis Set - 23/111 - Rare - Pokemon Card - Unlimited - NM $3.49 7 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Rare Neo Genesis Pokemon Unlimited Lightly Played 23/111 $2.25 8 weeks ago 💥 MAGBY - Pokemon 2000 Neo Genesis Non Holo Foil Vintage # 23/111 23/111 $1.16 8 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Neo Genesis English Pokemon Cards Excellent $2.00 8 weeks ago Pokemon : Neo Genesis Magby 23/111 Rare Unlimited LP 23/111 $5.63 8 weeks ago Magby 23/111 Neo Genesis Pokemon Card Rare WOTC 2000 - LP 23/111

3 sales well outside the rest ($9.29, $9.95, $11.95). A median is barely moved by them, which is why it is the number shown.

Also held for this card: 1 CGC 10, 1 PSA 9. Priced separately, never mixed into this median.

Every sale is a completed listing. Click any line to open it.

Price by grade
2 from real sales · 2 est
Grade PSA CGC BGS SGC
10
$77.00
est
$35.00
est
9
—
—
8.5
—
—
—
8
—
—
—
7
—
—
—
6
—
—
—
4
—
—
—
3
—
—
—

Medians of completed sales — click one to see them. Arrows compare the last 90 days with the period before. last sold means one or two sales, so we show the most recent one rather than a median. est is an estimate we have not confirmed. pop is how many exist at that grade. How we price

Grade it? 13% of 150 PSA-graded copies came back a 10. Raw $2.74 → PSA 10 $59.00. Expected value after a $60 fee: $-24.04 per copy.
Run the full math → Is yours a 10? Pre-grade it, $3 or we grade it for you, $27
Sales volume: Top 40% of cards
Buy on DoubleHolo
Buy on eBay Buy on TCGplayer Should I grade it?
Price History
Raw PSA 10
Graded by
PSA
150
graded
13.3%
20 in PSA 10
CGC
131
graded
12.2%
16 at 10 or better
How CGC grades work
CGC grades above 9: Pristine sits above Gem Mint, Perfect above that.
Pristine 10 2 Gem Mint 10 14 9.5 1 9 29

These are two different pools of submissions, so this compares what each grader did, not what either would do with the same card.

Population Distribution

PSA 10 20
PSA 9 57
PSA 8 34
PSA 7 15
PSA 6 12
PSA 5 5
PSA 4 3
PSA 3 4
PSA 2 0
PSA 1 0

Affiliate disclosure: as an eBay Partner Network affiliate, PokeInvest earns from qualifying purchases made through eBay links on this page. The Double Holo button is a paid sponsorship.

eBay Listings BETA

Loading eBay listings...

Buy on DoubleHolo
View More on eBay

Similar Cards

Xatu [1st Edition] #52 from Pokemon Neo Genesis set
Xatu [1st Edition] #52
Same Set
$2.99
Quilava #46 from Pokemon Neo Genesis set
Quilava #46
Same Set
$3.00
Stantler [1st Edition] #76 from Pokemon Neo Genesis set
Stantler [1st Edition] #76
Same Set
$2.98
Sentret [1st Edition] #71 from Pokemon Neo Genesis set
Sentret [1st Edition] #71
Same Set
$2.98
Mantine [1st Edition] #64 from Pokemon Neo Genesis set
Mantine [1st Edition] #64
Same Set
$2.97
Time Capsule [1st Edition] #90 from Pokemon Neo Genesis set
Time Capsule [1st Edition] #90
Same Set
$3.03
More on this card: Compare graders PSA 10 price & pop Should you grade it? Every Magby card Neo Genesis PSA population